Who was it?
It's ok if you don't want to say the name of this 'brilliant' driver, but if it was that M Schumacher guy (not the one in coma right now...
) that would explain pretty much everything - and he was kicked/banned anyway, so we don't need to worry about him.
And I'm sorry, but again, I have to disagree with you...
I mean... all of the points you used to 'defend' the use of a formation lap - the drivers behaviour and etc - only shows that we're not 'ready' for it yet and it's kinda 'obvious' to me that we would have at least a few issues here and there during some formation laps - maybe not after a while, that's true though.
BUT...
As I said before, I still think it doesn't bring ANY real bennefit to the league or to the races.
As you said yourself you don't even care about tyre and brakes temps and as I said before, only the formation lap is NOT enough to heat them up anyway - in most mods, but especially in this one, the car needs at least 2 laps in full race speed to get all warmed up, so it's OBVIOUS that a formation lap in a low speed would NOT be enough and it wouldn't change ANYthing on the starting temps - so IF the formation lap was for that purpose only, it would be pointless already.
And IF the other purpose of the formation lap is having it 'just because it's fun and/or more realistic'... then we gotta go back to what you've just said above... We KNOW some issues may happen and we also KNOW it wouldn't be fun at all when they do... - not to mention that it's just not practical for our league 'settings', like when we have some test races and lots of restarts - I know that so many restarts shouldn't happen, but adding a formation lap to the test races won't avoid the restarts to happen, even if they don't happen so oftenly anymore. But even if we need 1 or 2 restarts, in each time we have to call them, we would have to take the whole formation lap again (what about Belgium and other long circuits?! Geez!!..) - and believe me: formation laps in the test races are even worse than in the official race - people are even LESS responsible - so it would only make people annoyed, upset and in the end it would just be a big waste of time.
So, long story short: as I said before, in MY PERSONAL OPINION.. I think formation lap is a bad idea because it's unnecessary to the league (not something we 'must have' in our races) and also just literally a waste of time, tyres, fuel and patience, which could brings us more issues than bennefits.
The final decision comes from the LAT anyway and if most admins and/or most drivers really want formation lap, it's not the end of the world to me, but still here's my opinion and reasons why I don't think it's a good idea or gain to the league.